Mana Incubator

Thewhitedragon69

Been playing with card designs, mainly for Modern/Pioneer, and came up with a card that might be good across the board, but not particularly broken (I don't think).

https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/mana-incubator

My main concept was to design a card that could ramp to 4 mana on turn 2 in Pioneer, but would come at the expense of being vulnerable and costing your turn 1 without being reusable. It would also be useless in tron builds in modern, mostly, as it needs colored mana to cast and takes up the time needed for turn 1 map/stirrings.

Thoughts?

My thoughts are make it black to cast and activate as a throwback to Dark Ritual

evouga

The last sentence should be changed to something like:

Add 3 mana of any one color used to pay Mana Incubator's mana cost.

The second sentence doesn't really work under the rules:

Mana Incubator's mana cost must be paid with mana of any color.

However if you delete this sentence I think it would work as you intended: you could activate its sacrifice ability, but the ability would do nothing if no mana was paid to cast the Incubator, or if you paid with colorless mana.

Oh, a fantasy card thread. Haven't had one of those in a while.

Griselbrother

@80percentbuffoon said in Mana Incubator:

Oh, a fantasy card thread. Haven't had one of those in a while.

Is this the only comment you make on this board?

@griselbrother said in Mana Incubator:

@80percentbuffoon said in Mana Incubator:

Oh, a fantasy card thread. Haven't had one of those in a while.

Is this the only comment you make on this board?

I also complement good Vintage original content. Unfortunately I haven't seen an opportunity to work that muscle in a while.

Griselbrother

@80percentbuffoon said in Mana Incubator:

@griselbrother said in Mana Incubator:

@80percentbuffoon said in Mana Incubator:

Oh, a fantasy card thread. Haven't had one of those in a while.

Is this the only comment you make on this board?

I also complement good Vintage original content. Unfortunately I haven't seen an opportunity to work that muscle in a while.

Well, you could try posting some yourself

@griselbrother said in Mana Incubator:

@80percentbuffoon said in Mana Incubator:

@griselbrother said in Mana Incubator:

@80percentbuffoon said in Mana Incubator:

Oh, a fantasy card thread. Haven't had one of those in a while.

Is this the only comment you make on this board?

I also complement good Vintage original content. Unfortunately I haven't seen an opportunity to work that muscle in a while.

Well, you could try posting some yourself

Bold of you to say that an hour and a half after I did.