I did not do any deep analysis about that but my fear is : what if people find out that mulligan agressively into hate is the best strategy under that mulligan rule ? It would lead in not very interesting games where the winner would be the one who found the hate in fewer mulligan than his opponent.
This is why dredge under the London Mulligan is not so scary to me.
Not sure that matters but no,
It does not matter in the least for validity of argument. These are of course all opinions and we all have our reasons for wanting certain restrictions or unrestrictions. The question was purely out of curiosity to see if there is any sharp divide in thought between the paper community and the online community.
We are about 3 weeks out from the 4th Vintage event of the year for Deal Me In Games. This times the prizes are bigger and better than ever. That's right, our April 14th event will be an NYSE qualifier with the winner of this event earning a free entry to the upcoming NYSE event.
Starting at NOON on Sunday, March 10 we have our monthly store tournament.
Jason at Deal Me In Games
15 proxy Type 1 tournament (Vintage for you young 'uns)
127 East Philadelphia Ave
Boyertown, PA 19512
Sunday, April 14 at 12 Noon
So we can get together and have fun playing Magic the Gathering in its best format ever for some kickass prizes. ***
PLEASE NOTE THE FOLLOWING CHANGES TO PRIZES
***Starting with our January tournament, all prize payouts will be in cash. That's right, you walk in with cash for an entry fee and cards to play and walk out with cold hard cash in hand. Payouts will be based on attendance. The entry fee remains at $35. $5 from each entrant each and every month goes towards to the end of year invitational prizes (2018 we had a mishra's workshop and underground sea for 1st and 2nd). $5 towards the host store and $25 per person goes towards the prize pool. 100% of prize pool payout goes towards top 8 (depending on attendance, may be top 4).
Also this month, at no additional charge, the winner of the April tournament will get a free entry to the upcoming NYSE event!
Because this is a cash payout, please bring cash for the entry fee.
***Also note Jason's new promotion - if you bring a new player who has not played Vintage at DMIG in the past, you get a break on your entry fee (this does not affect the amount in the prize pool).
As always, this monthly event also will earn each participant points towards Deal Me In Games 2019 Invitational. Each win is 3 points. Each loss is 1 point and a draw is 2 points. The standings year to date are:
I really think its time Vintage went to a B&R&S list - Banned ( 0 copies) Restricted (2 copies max) and Singleton (1 copy max).
The only argument ever presented against this that I have seen is that it could be too confusing for new players. What new players?
There are plenty of new players on MTGO. The online format is thriving.
Doesn't that take away the problem of remembering how many of each you can have? Its all programmed in so if you have a 2 of and try to add a third it tells you the deck is now illegal. Or does mtgo not do that?
Our invitational standings are getting exciting. Greg Hoover narrowly holds onto the #1 seed for the second month in a row, holding off a charging Ryan McKinney by 1 point. Dan Barkon, who missed this event, is still in the top 8 and tied for 6th/7th/8th place with Evan Hunterdmark and Joe Brennan.
Dean Harris and Jason Beaupre are 1 event away from muscling into the mix.
Nic DiJohn, Stephen Ganter and Ryan Glackin are making a good push with their point totals to stay within striking distance.
Stephen Harvey, though he is 12 points out of the top 8 has only been to 1 event. A few more showings like that and he's in.
1 Hoover Greg 43
2 McKinney Ryan 42
3 Greb Chuck 39
4 Dobbin Zach 38
5 Barkon Joshua 34
6 Barkon Dan 30
7 Hunterdmark Evan 30
8 Brennan Joe 30
13 people showed up at Deal Me In Games in the heart of downtown Boyertown, Pa today to do battle. No clear winner was decided as Chuck Greb and Stephen Harvey smashed their way thru the top 8, the top 4 then decided to split the finals. Congratulations to Chuck and Stephen both for great days at the tables.
Our top 8 was:
Greg Hoover vs Chuck Greb Chuck took it 2-1
Dean Harris vs Ryan McKinney Ryan wins 2-1
Zach Dobbin vs Joe Brennan Joe wins 2-0
Stephen Harvey vs Stephen Ganter Stephen H wins 2-0
In the top 4 we had:
Stephen Harvey defeat Joe Brennan 2-0
Chuck Greb defeat Ryan McKinney 2-0
In the finals:
Stephen Harvey and Chuck Greb split
Top 8 decklists will be posted by Jason a bit later. But to the best of my knowledge:
Greg Hoover - Ravager shops
Dean Harris - Dark Depths
Zach Dobbins - Dredge
Stephen Harvey - delver/pyro
Chuck Greb - some creative delver monstrosity
Ryan McKinney - Titan Oath
Joe Brennan -
Stephen Ganter - esper control
We had a pretty diverse meta with 13 players and at least 9 distinctly different decks.
2 shops - 1 ravager, 1 blue shops
1 white eldrazi
2 oath variants
2 PO decks
2 delver decks
1 one-card monte comb
1 dark depths
1 chuck greb
Thank you all who came out today. And we will see everybody next the second sunday of April for our next tournament. That is Sunday, April 14!
Invitational standings in the next post.