Love VSL in general, it's what got me into really liking Vintage and now I own far too many digital pixels and decks.
Really dislike how the format makes the metagame super inbred and how much certain people use that platform to complain.
Also sad we won't be seeing Nick D. in the play-in again this season, but yay for @Brass-Man!
I like the idea of the DCI being active in attempting to manage the Vintage format. I like the idea of restricting and unrestricting cards just for the purpose of shaking things up and shifting the format in addition to preventing it from getting unhealthy (this is something I feel they did with Gush's unrestriction, and I think that was successful at least for a while).
IMO if you want a format that rotates go play Standard or Modern.
@Leoj Untrue. rotating say, Scourge out of a format would be very different from just banning Mind's Desire.
You're splitting hairs. What the DCI does with Modern is essentially forcing rotation particularly in cases like Twin where it isn't a dominant deck and they're doing it to "shake up" the format before a PT.