Posts made by thelastgnu
posted in Single-Card Discussion read more

@fsecco You've got to think "less playable Fastbond decks". My mind immediately jumped to high tide combo.

posted in Vintage Tournaments read more

Classic angle shot. Trick the competition into showing up on the wrong day.

posted in Single-Card Discussion read more

@griselbrother It's just Wizards pushing the gaudy silver artifact frame for brand recognition!

posted in Single-Card Discussion read more

@thewhitedragon69 Definitely not saying it's an unwinnable position, just sharing my unfavorable experience. It feels like Karn (and to a lesser extent Narset) is a bit different from previous iterations, and I'm unconvinced that creatures are an apt solution to it. The "selection factor" of its CA effect just does so much more than say Jace's, and the value of that selection scales rapidly with the power level of the format's card pool.

They've already got the Burning Wish. Your creature advantage is just to clean up the leftover Null Rod, second Wish, and incidental value. I would argue that artifacts is a far more potent overlap with SB tech than sorceries to boot.

I don't think it's necessarily an intractable problem for the format, but I do think it presents a different set of challenges that running more creatures won't adequately address.

posted in Single-Card Discussion read more

@thewhitedragon69 Anecdotally speaking, having played a bit of Survival lately: I feel like a dog when Karn or Narset resolves. And I certainly don't feel like I've come out far ahead if/when I knock one out.

Karn can be especially punishing if they manage Lattice/Time Vault/Batterskull/Wurmcoil. But even assuming just cage from the board, it's still

{4}: Opponents can't Vengevine for the rest of the game, gain 4 life

posted in Single-Card Discussion read more

@desolutionist Understand it's sort of missing your point, but wanted to take an opportunity to plug panard's MTGO docker image, which has been near-flawless for me.

posted in Single-Card Discussion read more

I've just consulted the comp rules, and it seems a little uncivilized... but if I'm understanding correctly, you can actually just pay mana for phyrexian costs.

posted in Single-Card Discussion read more

@chubbyrain Satisfying a curious itch: guess it's like 12% with 4 Lavinia, 16 lands, and 1 each: Pearl, Sapphire, Petal, and Lotus.
Assuming only 12 of those lands can actually produce U/W: 10%

Disclaimer: all real math lazily disregarded for programmatic sampling.

posted in Single-Card Discussion read more

@fsecco Weirdly enough, I think modern Workshops' aggro focus probably makes the ability pretty lackluster for stabilization once you get to six. Specifically: it's worth noting that the +1/+1 counters from Ballistae, Walkers, Ravagers, and Overseers stick around.

For a significant chunk of the creature package, this ability reads: Up to two target creatures get +0/+3 and lose all activated abilities. Not nothing, but might actually be more interesting in the more-controlling, unrestricted Lodestone meta.

posted in Vintage Community read more

Gifts, because I can't quit Mana Drain, no matter how unplayable it gets.

posted in Workshops read more

@Serracollector I don't think that works as well as one would hope; those aren't triggers.

posted in Vintage Community read more

Having been on the other side of this in a previous P9 challenge, I must admit it was originally somewhat disheartening to watch the replay and discover that I was facing down 2 players, plus a third over Skype.

That said, I know that I personally got a lot out of being able to re-watch that match from my opponent's point of view; to hear the considerations of his lines, see what he had, and especially to hear the debate between different lines. It was a wealth of valuable information that you just cannot get anywhere else. I was able to easily pick out my (very) loose plays, see where I had my windows, and when they closed. I lost the match, but was able to get a heck of a return on that loss.

My two cents: I definitely wouldn't want to see an end to the way that Vintage has been streamed recently -- the community, entertainment and educational value provided is far and away worth more than the occasional feelbads.

posted in Vintage Community read more

@xouman

Planeswalker legend rule sends the "used" one to the graveyard, new titan token brings a now-refreshed Saheeli back from the yard.

posted in Single-Card Discussion read more

@Serracollector

CMC zero on moxen makes this a bit of a non-bo. I don't know that I see it working outside of older style prison shops.

posted in Single-Card Discussion read more

@Serracollector You'll draw 10 cards before you lose any life.

posted in TheManaDrain Metadiscussion read more

@jimmycolorado
It's the OP's avatar on the far left. Clicking the picture will turn it into a check box.